Amazon vs eBay in 2025: Which Platform Should New Cross-Border Sellers Choose?

As a budding cross-border e‑commerce seller, choosing the right platform—Amazon or eBay—can make or break your success. In 2025, both marketplaces remain strong but cater to different strategies, costs, and consumer expectations. Let’s explore their core differences across logistics, trust, fees, and target audiences to discover which fits your goals best.

‍

1. Business Models & Seller Experience

• Amazon is structured for B2C and branded businesses, offering standardized tools like Amazon Prime and Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA).
• eBay, as a C2C auction-style marketplace, empowers individual sellers to list new, used, and collectible items with more flexibility.

‍

2. Logistics & Fulfillment

• Amazon Prime delivers fast nationwide shipping (2-day) and seamless returns through FBA (+30-day unconditional returns).
• eBay depends on seller-managed shipping—typically slower (~5‑day delivery) with returns handled privately.

‍

3. Trust & Brand Perception

• Amazon lends seller credibility by minimizing direct seller visibility and managing the entire sales process.
• eBay is known for deals on pre-owned or unique items, but may raise buyer warnings due to varied seller reputations.

‍

4. Cost Structure Comparison

eBay’s listing costs are generally lower, while Amazon charges for platform management—but Amazon covers logistics via FBA fees.

‍

5. Target Customer & Market Reach

• Amazon serves over 300 million registered users, primarily in North America, with 14 global marketplaces.
• eBay has ~147 million users and 27 international sites, with more global buyer activity outside the U.S.

‍

Which One Should You Choose?

• Opt for eBay if:
  • You sell low-cost, used, or collectible items
  • You want to keep listing costs low and manage your own logistics
  • You target global buyers seeking bargains
• Choose Amazon if:
  • You prefer a more automated, scalable setup
  • You can handle small monthly fees for brand-building and FBA benefits
  • You want access to a massive, fast-moving marketplace with Prime-certified services

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Your best choice depends on your products, budget, and expansion goals. Many sellers thrive with a multi-channel strategy—listing on both platforms to hedge risks, reach more customers, and grow sales steadily.